2024-25
Ray'Sean Taylor, OVC Player of the Year/All-OVC First Team
Brian Taylor II, All-OVC Second Team
2023-24
Damarco Minor, All-OVC First Team
2022-23
Ray'Sean Taylor, All-OVC First Team
Damarco Minor, OVC All-Newcomer Team
2021-22
Ray'Sean Taylor, OVC All-Newcomer Team
2017-18
Jalen Henry, All-OVC Second Team
2013-14
Donivine Stewart, OVC All Newcomer Team
2011-12
Mark Yelovich, All-OVC Second Team
Jerome Jones, OVC All Newcomer Team
2008-09
Mark Yelovich, All-Independent Honorable Mention
2007-08
T.J. Gray, 2nd team
2006-07
J.B. Jones, Honorable Mention
Mike Hardiek , Honorable Mention
2005-06
Ryan Belcher, 2nd team
Ty Johnson, 2nd team
J.B. Jones, 2nd team
2004-05
Tim Bauersachs, 1st team
Dan Heimos, 2nd team
J.B. Jones, Honorable mention
J.B. Jones, Freshman of the Year
2002-03
Justin Ward, Freshman of the Year
2001-02
Marty Perry, Honorable mention
2000-01
Marty Perry, Honorable mention
1998-99
Travis Wallbaum, 2nd team
Antonio McKinzie, Honorable mention
Ben Wierzba , Honorable mention
1997-98
Nathan Kreke, 2nd team
Rusty Sarnes , Honorable mention
1996-97
Jason Holmes, Honorable mention
1995-96
Jason Holmes, 2nd team
1995-2008 (Great Lakes Valley)
2008-2009 (Division I Independent)
2011-present (Ohio Valley Conference)
