SIUE

First Team
Les Agne (1979)
Les Agne (1980)
Bob Gaus (1983)

Second Team
Brooks Brestal (1977)
Keith Gocal (1987)

Third Team
Les Agne (1978)
Tim Gehrig (1979)
Mark Hofstetter (1980)
Keith Gocal (1986)

Honorable Mention
Mark Boyajian (1971)
Dave Riffey (1975)
Kevin McConnell (1977)
Les Agne (1977)
Tim Gehrig (1978)
Mark Hofstetter (1979)
Bob Gaus (1981)
Jay Eihausen (1981)
Bob Donnewald (1982)
Jay Eihausen (1982)
Jay Eihausen (1983)
Mark Marcuzzo (1984)
Steve Nolawski (1989)
Bill Willis (1990)

GCAA All-American Scholar
Taylor Cox (2014)
Taylor White (2014)
Bill Willis (1990)
Danny Gorman (2017)
Brady Dixon (2018)
Conor Dore (2018)
Austin Glendinning (2018)
Danny Gorman (2018)
Kyle Slattery (2018)
Conor Dore (2019)
Grant Gavin (2019)
Kyle Slattery (2019)
Will Starkey (2019) 
Brooks Jungbluth (2020)
Parker McEachern (2020)
Presley Mackelburg (2020)
Zak Butt (2021)
Parker McEachern (2021)
Anthony Ruthey (2021)
TJ Baker (2022)
Luke Ludwig (2022)
Presley Mackelburg (2022)
Anthony Ruthey (2022)
TJ Baker (2023)
Alex Eickhoff (2023)
Presley Mackelburg (2023)
Anthony Ruthey (2023)
TJ Baker (2024)
Anthony Ruthey (2024)
Luke Ludwig (2024)
Brady Kaufmann (2024)
Alex Eickhoff (2024)