Ohio Valley Conference
2025 - Alex Eickhoff (First Team), Brady Kaufmann (First Team), Will Simpson (Second Team, All-Newcomer Team)
2024 - TJ Baker (Player of the Year), Brady Kaufmann, Luke Ludwig, Brent Reintjes (All-Newcomer Team)
2023 - Anthony Ruthey (First Team), Brady Kaufmann (Freshman of the Year, All-Newcomer Team), Alex Eickhoff (All-Newcomer Team)
2022 - TJ Baker (First Team)Â
2021 - Zak Butt (All-Newcomer Team), TJ Baker (All-Newcomer Team)
2020 - Tanner Collins (All-Newcomer Team)
2019 - Kyle Slattery (First Team), Conor Dore (First Team), Brooks Jungbluth (All-Newcomer Team)
2018 - Kyle Slattery (First Team), Jordan Harre (First Team)
2017 - Luke Long (First Team, Freshman of the Year)
2014 - Jordan Peters (All-Newcomer team)
2013 - Colin McCarty (First Team)
2012 - Mitchell Homb (All-Newcomer team)
Great Lakes Valley Conference
2007 - Kyle Lickenbrock
2006 - Craig Heinzmann, Kyle Gansauer
